Ship agent failed to verify disposal costs in advance

Mutual insurer ITIC, a major provider of professional indemnity insurance to the entire transport sector, including marine, reports in its latest claims review of a case where a ship agent in Australia was asked by their principal to arrange for the disposal of dunnage and other materials related to the packing of cargo upon the ship’s arrival. Australia has strict local quarantine regulations.

The agent’s employee engaged the services of a licensed disposal company that had previously been used to dispose of ship’s garbage and other more hazardous waste. This was not the company that the agents usually used to dispose of dunnage. The agent relayed instructions to the disposal company over the telephone, but failed to verify the total cost.

The materials were disposed of and the disposal company sent a bill for around A$70,000. The owners questioned the unusually high charges, but the disposal company said that they had charged their usual rate for licensed waste disposal.

The agent made inquiries and confirmed the amount their usual dunnage disposal company would charge to deal with dunnage and packing materials would have been about A$7,000.

The owner was unwilling to pay more than the reasonable costs which should have been incurred, that being A$7,000. The agent had been negligent in their selection of the disposal company and was liable for the payment of the invoiced amount.

ITIC reimbursed the agent for the balance of the invoiced amount, A$63,000.


https://www.itic review/article/dunnage disposal 143459/